Your Band Will Break Up - Prepare Ahead of Time
Being Prepared For Band Breakups
?You need to realize that there are probably about 4 bands who haven't broke up. The other 100 billion bands have had to split even if they later put the band back together. Because of this, you not only need to be aware that the band will not last forever and have a plan for dealing with that, but you also need to be aware of the factors that you can control so that you can avoid breaking up (and hopefully make better music in the process).
Why Does A Band Breakup?
There are a million reasons that a band may break up. These range from everything from the drummer getting a little naughty with your girlfriend to differences in goals or ambition. Some of these can be controlled (like the drummer), but some of these can not. Here is just a short list of what causes in bands and maybe a few tips to stop these problems for escalating.
Communication
Without a doubt, the best way to keep a band a band is to keep communication as strong and open as possible. When all the band members feel like they can say anything that is on their mind, the entire band gets stronger...more like a family. When something is bothering the rhythm guitar player, the ability to let everyone know this is crucial. Of course, if no one listens to the rhythm guitar player when he has a problem, communication has broken done. Mr. Rhythm guitar won't be stating his opinion much anymore.
Because of this, it's very important to address any problem that comes up. If the bass player really doesn't like the chorus of a song, it's important for everyone to sit down and talk about it. If you don't even discuss the issue, the bass player will feel small. It's important for every member of the band to feel like they are contributing. If a person's ideas are being ignored, without realizing it, you are tearing your band apart.
When you sit down to discuss the issues with the chorus, you need to be realistic. The odds of 5 people entirely loving a chorus on a song are slim. Music is so subjective and you'll find that bands try to put some sort of objective spin on songwriting decisions hoping to improve their success. If 4 out of 5 people really like a song, the band is probably on the right track. However, if you handle this poorly, you'll find that you'll have one less band member eventually.
So sit down and discuss the issue. Make whoever has the problem feel like their opinion matters. (It should!). Maybe make a compromise so that the guy with the problem is happy. You'll find him a much stronger contributer to the band when they feel like they are a necessary element.
Personally, I thought nothing improved our communication like drinking a little too much beer. There is something to speaking honestly and freely about a topic that can only occur when your inhibitions have been reduced. Just make sure you don't overdo it too often.
Pages: « Back 1 2 3 4 Next »
|
Recording Forum
If you have a question, please post on the Recording Forum.
Comments
-
Comment #1
(Posted by Swifton)
Rating





Good article! If you don't mind I'm going to direct my readers to it. It's one of those topics I have found that other members rarely want to talk about unless, as you point out, big bucks (in equipment) is involved.
Thanks!
-
Comment #2
(Posted by Maya)
Rating





I got on-line today looking for an article just like this because I have decided to leave a band I've been with for 7 years.
I found a lot of information in the article that pertained to us (me). Unfortunately, the damage has been done and I don't see any other resolution but to leave the band. It is very hard. My sister is in the band along with my 2 best friends. But, if we want to stay friends, I've got to get out.
Thanks,
-
Comment #3
(Posted by EpiTheT)
Rating





Very good article! there is no "right way" or a formula to keep your band together, but the problems pointed out here are very real.
-
Comment #4
(Posted by Coma, Separated)
Rating





I wish i read this article a month ago. i'm sure you could guess why...
-
Comment #5
(Posted by lisa)
Rating





Er, girls play in bands too you know! it's not all cock rock, but the points are still good ones....
-
Comment #6
(Posted by Sal)
Rating





I liked this article... my band just broke up right as we had interest from an agent and even bigger venue's... we started booking more gigs at $500 per show but the monkey of booking the shows was constantly on my back... we had a friend starting to help book shows but all the failures were pushed on my shoulders rather than everyone taking an equitable stake in the success... i now have several bands pursuing my time and am sure to be much smarter about it the second time around...
-
Comment #7
(Posted by Cory)
Rating





I'm really glad you wrote this...I am a lead guitarist/songwriter for my band, Last N Line and I would just like to say that this article has helped me realize what I have to do to keep my bandmates interested and in line...I've already replaced a bass player and a drummer, which happened to be my best friend. If only I would have read this article sooner, my band would have been saved.
-
Comment #8
(Posted by poliwog)
Rating





Absolutely dead on! I'm sorry my beand members didn't read this before it came to my husband and I leaving the band. You got it dead right in our case, communication break down, not listening, and us having more ambition than everyone else, who was perfectly happy playing every other month rather the two a month we agreed on. Glad to be supported!
-
Comment #9
(Posted by Anonymous)
Rating





Wow. thats helpful.
i'm really glad i've read this. me and my friends started a band about a year ago and its pretty much been a slowly dying gimped cow ever since.
Me (lead guitarist) and the drummer are talking about breaking up the band and starting a new one for various reasons (lack of skill, conflicting genres, etc.)
but i'm really glad i've read this. when we start another band i'll know what needs to be done and more importantly avoided.
thanks.
-
Comment #10
(Posted by Mel)
Rating





I was in a band for about 7 yrs. The not too talented and stage freightened bass player has a home recording studio we me and my other guy depended on :( + lack of communication..result: downfall of a unique world music in DC. I wish I've read the article before the damage!!
-
Comment #11
(Posted by Adan)
Rating





My last band of three and a half years recently broke up and I could not agree with more with the things you have said. We played 150 plus shows in that time, recorded three cd's (2 of which were recorded in major studios), got in contact with some record labels, had plenty of merch etc etc and all it took was a few STUPID little fights to ruin everything. It is so important in a band to be able to communicate. Without that, the band has nothing. Also, dont even consider playing with someone who will never communicate. In my band's situation, once problems arose, the guitar player absolutely refused to sit and talk about anything at all. No surprise the band broke up a month later.
Submit Comment