»  Article Archive  »  Blogs  »  When Did "Hit Songs" Become Garbage?
Article Archive

You are currently viewing the old system for RecordingReview.com articles. There are over 200 articles to improve the quality of your recordings in this archive, however, all new articles can be found in the new Recording Blog.

Brandon Drury
Owner of Echo Echo Studios, Brandon Drury, has recorded and mixed over 600 songs in his very busy home recording studio.  

View all blogs by Brandon Drury...
When Did "Hit Songs" Become Garbage?
By Brandon Drury | Published  08/31/2006

Most of us who have been listening to music for a while are not all that happy with the things are going, overall, in the music industry. I've noticed that some of my peers get a little bitey when I say my goal is to produce a "hit song". I know where they are coming from. For most music people (recording guys, band guys, etc) there haven't been that many hit songs that have done ANYTHING for them in the past 15 years. (I'm pretty sure I counted 10 songs in the Billboard Top 100 of the past

10 years that did anything for me. That's 10 out of 1000 songs!!!)


Luckily, I've been on a big time 80s kick for the past year or two. For whatever reason, songs that came out when I was 4 seam to bypass the scrutiny that I might put on a new song. When I say, "I want to produce a hit song", I don't mean I want to produce uncatchy garbage. I mean I want to produce songs that make other people feel like I do when I listen to "Your Love" by the Outfield or whatever.


Alright, so here is where it gets tricky. When did a "hit song" go from being the most catchy song to a "hit song" being total shit that should be despised? I noticed an enormous drop off in my opinion on pop music in the 1994-95 range. Is this just me showing my age or was there a obvious change in music?


There is no doubt that writing styles change. You can really see that in rap music (by far, not my favorite genre) because it's the genre with the least "shame". I've heard a few modern rap songs that are almost entirely monotone. I mean the vocals. I mean the "beats" or music behind the vocals. Everything. I just can't imagine how any person could feel excited about listening to monotone. However, these monotone songs are dominating the charts. They are hit songs making zillions of dollars. How?


In comparison, I have to admit that I own 2 rap cds. Dr. Dre "The Chronic" and Snoop Doggy Dogg "Doggystyle". I have a blast listening to those records even now. It is rap music, but there is a lot of music going on. There are differences in mood. Differences in emotion (admittedly not much in the vocals, though). At least the music was structured/created in a way to evoke some sort of feeling out the listener.


So how do we go from those to rap cds to a song with one sample being repeated the entire song? Is the Summer of '69 type of "hit song" dead? Clearly, the monotone stuff is effecting a lot of people....so therefor, is it legit? Should I look for the deeper meaning in the monotone stuff?


Brandon

 
Comments

  • Comment #1 (Posted by gonz)

    good observations, and the answer (to your last Q
    should I look for deeper meaning....)
    the answer is : NO, there is no deeper meaning in that crap bro, it's just noise with jungle drums
    you don't even need entonation to "sing" that abomination, just open their mouth and expel garbage,
    well that is monotone compared to melodic music,
    not to mention the words, pure basura, promotes
    violence, decadence, indecency, grafitti and obscenity, what a cultural contribution
     
  • Comment #2 (Posted by POP,S)

    I am 53 and they are no song that are being wrote for my age group any more and the labels can not understan why CD are not selling.I have not bought a cd in the last 20 years. They need to go back to the basic,
     
  • Comment #3 (Posted by Jim Arjuna)

    I agree. There is a lot of music, and the only music with good vocals seems to be country. But, I am not a big country fan. I like good old fashioned folk rock, rock, metal, blues, and blues rock style and intensity of emotion and songs with thought behind them. You know ones that mean something.
     
  • Comment #4 (Posted by Baron)

    I think that there is still plenty of great music being made and recorded but, most of it does not make the top 100, thanks to an ever more formularised record industry. There is good stuff out there but, just like trying to find the tiger in the jungle, it is just a much longer hunt nowadays.

    Baron

     
  • Comment #5 (Posted by ratman)

    I think musical perspective shifts with age. There's no real definition of 'good' or 'bad' music; all that matters is whether a given listener enjoys their time spent. So it's all relative to what your ears have been trained to hear and appreciate. 20 years from now people will likely begin to find novelty in today's current styles.

    I do believe, however, that there's a certain kind of "golden age" of recording in our history and that it's not likely to be duplicated again because of the pervasiveness of digital equipment.

    The use of voice pitch-correctors has also greatly contributed to the increasing sterility of today's music.
     
  • Comment #6 (Posted by Bandit)

    Rap Music is whole other world now and I can tell you some about it, considering that I'm a huge rap fan and a rapper. For the record, I'm also a huge fan of non-rap genres (everything from classical to 50's to disco to 80s rock to ...well, everything)... rap is about several things. (1) relatable content <<< especially to the young urban community. When a rap song "relates" to this audience, it is popular. (2) Reality. A lot of rap isn't [or is not supposed to be but still is] an imaginary thing. The idea is, it is real..at least that's what is propogated. This is why there is violence among the hip hop community. Many live up to what they're saying, or are forced to by the nature of the beast. (3)rap is rythmic not melodic..so if a jazz singer sings like a trumpet or scats.. a rapper is rapping like drums. Drums only have so many tones/notes. Of course there is variety. Some rappers rap melodically too. Some even sing. But the monotone thing is because the instruments rappers are mimicking or scatting after are rythmic instruments.
     
  • Comment #7 (Posted by Dan)

    Brandon: What the hell do you know about current music? You admitted a few days ago that you don't even know single CD that came out in 2008. ou just sound bitter and very ignorant in this article.
     
  • Comment #8 (Posted by Brandon Drury)

    Bitter? How did you get that? If I was meerly stating "I hate modern music" that would be one thing, but that's clearly not the case. I list specific problems that I hear dominating the radio and I'm asking what others think. It's an open discussion.

    As for the "modern" thing, I guess you missed the fact that this article was written in August of 2006 and is part of my old archive.

    Lastly, just because I don't know the name of an albums that have came out in 2008, I do leave my house from time to time. I get a frequent dose of the latest in pop music. The reason I'm not aware of these cd releases is because I'm very seldom impressed with what I hear on the radio....hence I wrote this article.

    Brandon
     
  • Comment #9 (Posted by Dan)

    I guess I missed the memo that explained how George Michael is a pop genius but Justin Timberlake is talentless.
     
  • Comment #10 (Posted by scott merring)

    Couldnt agree more. i dont know when MTV decided to stop being a music channel. i used to look to it for all the latest good songs. i used to love to see what the artists of my favorite songs would do to enhance their music visually. i grew up in the infancy ( and i mean that literally) of music video. i literally hatched it hatch, walk, grow wings, fly and crash and burn. all within about a dozen years. not a very long lifespan. but i'm starting to ramble and get off the subject. i'm at work right now and limited on time but i will finish this thought later...kudos on your article, Brandon.
     
  • Comment #11 (Posted by Tory)

    I enjoyed this article and I agree, for the most part, with Brandon. There are some good songs going on out there and some are even making some noise. I think the advent of My Space has helped to promote the lesser knowns like Colby Callait, one of the best new artists in my opinion. The jaunty piano girls are coming along nicely (Sarah Bareilles, etc) thanks to Tori Amos. The whiny piano guys (5 for Fighting, Keane, the Fray) have some excellent nuances of possible greatness. Maroon 5 is poised to be a musical force. On the downside are groups like Nickelback and 3 Doors Down who regurgitate the same sound over and over again. I believe there will be a Renaissance of music soon. Major labels are on the way out (who are perpetuating this boring age of music) and the indies will take over and show us how to enjoy music again.
    By the way, I loved The Outfield. I had both of their cds. It's a shame they couldn't go further.
    And yes, MTV is dead. I too grew up in it's infancy and was hooked on it. That was how you stayed "up" on music.
     
  • Comment #12 (Posted by Patrick Cortes)

    I certainly wouldn't write off all new music, you just need to know where to look. Like the last guy said, MySpace helps (and sometimes, makes things worse, as it allows an output for idiots who throw together a few generic crunk beats with a few generic lyrics and calls it music.)

    There's some really wonderful independent music out right now. People like Ingrid Michaelson or Joshua Radin or Cary Brothers who don't have to bend over for a record label are great.

    I'm a huge fan of Nine Inch Nails and I think Trent Reznor has some really fantastic ideas with the way he's distributing his music - basically by improving upon the system Radiohead went by. Radiohead, that's another good act out now. Tool is another great band but they only put something out about once every five years.

    There's great hip hop amid the horrible, horrible, HORRIBLE new trend of crunk music too. Common, Mos Def, Talib Kweli - all smart rappers who actually have something to say and an intelligent way, skillful and meaningful way of saying it. You'll never catch those fuckers on the top 40 because frankly most of America is too dumb for them, and somehow find it easier for this dispensible Soulja Boy garbage to hold their attention instead.
    There is some horrible shit on modern rock stations right now. Nickelback and 3 Doors Down do suck but to me the worst offender is Three Days Grace. Just horrible. Listen to those lyrics. They sound like they were written by a twelve year old.

    All in all, you just need to know where to look. I have an extremely wide taste in music, I'll give most things a good once-over if I see any hint of promise in it. That's all we can do - expand our musical horizons as best we can and try to whittle out all the bullshit.
     
  • Comment #13 (Posted by joe Kopecky)

    I agree to some extent but there is some quality music that is very popular. I'm a huge fan of 60's and 70's rock but I've found some music that I really like. I love Maroon 5, the vocals are great, the drum beats are awesome. I like matchbox 20 for similar reasons. One thing that I've noticed that's interesting is that some of the songs that have become bigger hits recently have used music from older music. The new Kid Rock song had the "warewolves of london" piano throughout the entire song, and he's not the first to ride off an older song's popularity.

    I think that the big problem with most music is that in a lot of cases people will listen to whatever is playing and like it just because it's what's there. I do believe that things are getting better, and that in the past few years music has been better than it was in the late 90's early 2000's.
     
  • Comment #14 (Posted by craig irwin)

    Well recently I've got
    cd's that are great in
    all facets.AC/DC Black Ice & Jeff Healey& also Metallica.
     
  • Comment #15 (Posted by speedball )

    nobody is going to have an 80s style hit record in the 2009 time frame
    aim at what will be big in 2010/2011 and do that if you want a hit
     
  • Comment #16 (Posted by Pallavi)

    Oh its really great musical blog. This songs are really nice. I used to download my favorite songs using freemp3. Well here i must share that i came to know about new free mp3 toolbar that allow to convert you tube videos to mp3 and allows you to download them to your computer. Try this to download your favorite songs(http://www.free-mp3.ca)

     
  • Comment #17 (Posted by Tony R)

    It seems to me that in general as people get older pop music being able to give people that wow factor when they hear a song that really grabs them begins to wane as they go through their late twenties and into their thirties. I can remember talking to a friend about how when we were younger thinking we would never become like our parents and not listen to pop music. How could we, it was just so neat and cool and all. Then we talked about how that is exactly what happened as we got older. It's not that a song can't grab me, it just does it so much less often and is harder for me to get that wow factor. Plus it just has to do with the style of music that is around when you are in the stage between 15 and 25. I don't know but that just seems to be the magic stage in life that whatever grabs you in that time period, grabs you the rest of your life. So many times I notice that people listen to the music that was popular during that age period of their lives. It has something to do with how our brain changes as we get older.

    Of course everyone is different. I knew someone who was just a little older than me who could listen to the current music and really get into it, which is a little unusual but nothing wrong with it. People say it is maturity like something we choose to do, but I really think it is just how our brains change as we get older plus the impression that the music of the time between age 15 and 25 somehow fusses with us for the rest of our lives.
     
  • Submit Comment